Awards  
 
 
 
 
 
OAFL BEST AND FAIREST
 
  Year Player OAFL MVP
  2009 Ajit Alister
  1997 Arnie Korpela
  1995 Rod Cutler
  1992 Mark Block
  1990 Mark Block
  1989 Tim Maud
 
OAFL ROOKIE OF THE YEAR
 
  Year Player OAFL Rookie
  1997 Luke Davies
  1994 Arnie Korpela
  1990 David Kerr
  1989 Patrick Grant
     
 
OAFL LEADING GOAL KICKER
 
  Year Player OAFL Goal Kicker
  2008 Troy Marsh (59)
  1999 Troy Marsh (44)
  1994-97 Mick Pearson
  1990-93 Peter Vitolis
  1989 Glen Walker (9)
     
 
TORONTO EAGLES BEST & FAIREST
 
  Year Player
  2009 Troy Marsh
  2008 Tarquin Netherway
  2007 Aaron Falcioni
  2006 Troy Marsh
  2005 Troy Marsh
  2004 Troy Marsh
  2003 Troy Marsh
  2002 Troy Marsh
  2001 Troy Marsh
  2000 Troy Marsh
  1999 Troy Marsh
  1998 Troy Marsh
  1997 Arnie Korpela
  1996 John Law
  1995 Rod Cutler
  1994 Mick Pearson
  1993 Dave Nelson
  1992 Graham Hewit
  1991 David Kerr
  1990 David Letch
  1989 Peter Vitols
     
TORONTO EAGLES CLUBMAN
 
  Year Player
  2009 Tom Hammond
  2008 Marc Nord
  2007 David Heward
     
     
TORONTO EAGLES ROOKIE OF THE YEAR
 
  Year Player
  2009 Chris Grey/Brent Jensen
  2008 Sukhjinder Bhangu
  2007 Aaron Lunadello
  2006 Frank Luisser
  2005 George Dimacakos
  2004 Kevin Minaker
  2003 Matt Bachinski
  2002 Taylor Hayward
  1999 Marc Nord
 
TORONTO EAGLES COACHES AWARD
 
  Year Player
  2009 Kevin Minaker
  2008 Matt Bachinski
  2007 Kevin Minaker